***ATTENTION! Online Order Fulfillment Paused. Orders Placed 2/14 - 2/20 will start shipping 2/21.***

Shipping Simplified: $7.95 Flat Rate, Free $69+ or Free Delivery ($39+) in Monroe County, NY

Check Our Freebies List!

All Orders $69+

Cart

No products in the cart.

Return To Shop
Shopping cart (0)
Subtotal: $0.00

View cart

Cart $0.00
2 columns grid
3 columns grid
4 columns grid
List
More
Show

Out of stock

Death By Chili Sauce - Mild- 12oz

Death By Chili Sauce - Mild – 12oz

$11.99
Size: 12oz
Read more

Out of stock

Death By Chili Sauce - Mild- 5oz

Death By Chili Sauce - Mild – 5oz

$7.99
Size: 5oz
Read more

Out of stock

Fresco Sauce Chi Banero Spicy Yellow Mustard

Fresco Sauce Chi Banero Spicy Yellow Mustard

$9.99
Chi Banero Spicy Yellow Mustard A garlicky blend of chipotle and orange habanero peppers with a hint of sweetness mixed in. Heat Level: Mild Gluten-Free and Vegan 8oz
Read more

Out of stock

Guglielmo's Butternut Squash Pasta Sauce

Guglielmo's Pasta Sauce – Butternut Squash

$7.99
Flavor: Butternut Squash
Read more

Out of stock

Guglielmo's Vodka Pasta Sauce

Guglielmo's Pasta Sauce – Vodka

$7.99
Flavor: Vodka
Read more

Out of stock

Guglielmo's Tomato Basil Pasta Sauce

Guglielmo's Pasta Sauce – Tomato Basil

$7.99
Flavor: Tomato Basil
Read more

Out of stock

Guglielmo's Sunday Pasta Sauce

Guglielmo's Pasta Sauce – Sunday

$7.99
Flavor: Sunday
Read more

Out of stock

Guglielmo's Pumpkin Pasta Sauce

Guglielmo's Pasta Sauce – Pumpkin

$7.99
Flavor: Pumpkin
Read more

Out of stock

Sale!
HCO - Aioli

HCO Aioli

Original price was: $7.99.Current price is: $3.00.
Aioli by Hot Crispy Oil BEST BY DATE: 3/1/26 This sauce is beyond its listed “Best By” Date. While this is not the same as an actual “expiration” date, we like to offer our hot sauce fans a significant discount if we are...
Read more

Out of stock

Henry's Garlic Parm Buff Sauce

Henry’s Garlic Parm Buff Sauce

(1 Review)

$8.99
Haus-Sauce Henry’s Garlic Parm Buff Sauce Introducing Henry’s Garlic Parm Buff Sauce. This delectable blend of garlic, parmesan, and heat will elevate your culinary creations. Contains: Milk, Soybean 16oz
Read more

Out of stock

Historic Lynchburg Jalapeno Pepper Ketchup

Historic Lynchburg Jalapeno Pepper Ketchup

$8.99
Jalapeno Pepper Ketchup A ketchup with a double kick, one of the heat from the red-ripened jalapenos, and the other from the genuine Jack Daniels Black Label Whiskey! Ingredients: Tomato Concentrate, Red Ripe Jalapeno Peppers, Distilled Vinegar, Corn Syrup, Salt, Spices, Garlic Powder,...
Read more

Out of stock

Historic Lynchburg Octoberfest Spiced Curry Ketchup

Historic Lynchburg Octoberfest Spiced Curry Ketchup

$5.99
Octoberfest Spiced Curry Ketchup A medium-heat spicy ketchup seasoned with curry spice and Jack Daniel’s Whiskey. Heat Rating: Medium 15oz
Read more

Out of stock

Historic Lynchburg WorcesterFIRE Steak Sauce

Historic Lynchburg WorcesterFire Steak Sauce

$7.99
Historic Lynchburg WorcesterFire Steak Sauce Not just great for steak. Use it as a marinade of a dipping sauce. Mild in heat but heavy on the flavor. 6oz
Read more

Out of stock

Sale!
Jawndiments Long Hot Mayo

Jawndiments Mayo – Long Hot Pepper

Original price was: $8.99.Current price is: $3.00.
Flavor: Long Hot Pepper
Read more

Out of stock

Sale!
Jawndiments Cherry Pepper Mayo

Jawndiments Mayo – Cherry Pepper

Original price was: $8.99.Current price is: $3.00.
Flavor: Cherry Pepper
Read more

Out of stock

Jersey Barnfire Salt & Pepper Ketchup

Jersey Barnfire Salt & Pepper Ketchup

$9.99
Jersey Barnfire Salt & Pepper Ketchup All things you’d expect from a Jersey Diner! A scratch ketchup pumped up with salt, pepper, and habaneros. Ingredients: Vinegar, water, sugar, tomato paste (tomatoes, citric acid), Habanero mash (habanero peppers, vinegar), salt, spices, xanthan gum
Read more

Out of stock

Sale!
You're My Boy Blue Mustard

Julz’s Creations You’re My Boy, Blue! Mustard

(1 Review)

Original price was: $4.99.Current price is: $3.99.
You’re My Boy, Blue! Mustard A 2021 International Flavor Awards winner. Great on hot dogs, burgers, wings, and as a pretzel dip. Ingredients: Local banana peppers, Mustard (Distilled Vinegar, Water, #1 Grade Mustard Seed, Salt, Turmeric, Natural Flavors, Spices), Distilled Vinegar, Sugar, Clear...
Read more

Out of stock

Momma K's Chicken Wing Dip

Momma K’s Chicken Wing Dip

(2 Reviews)

$12.99
Momma K’s Chicken Wing Dip Momma K’s chicken wing dip has been a staple of the Momma K family for years, and they are now excited to bring it to you! Made with real chicken and packed with flavor, it’s the ultimate game...
Read more

Out of stock

PepperNutz Buffalo Wing Sauce

PepperNutz Buffalo-Style Wing Sauce

$7.99
PepperNutz Buffalo-Style Chicken Wing Sauce This crowd pleaser features aged Cayenne and Habanero peppers, agave nectar, a hint of hickory smoke and other goodies, to provide an amazing ready-to-go wing sauce right out of the bottle. Heat Level: Medium Ingredients: Louisiana Hot Sauce (Aged...
Read more

Out of stock

Red Osier Beef Au Jus Gravy

Red Osier Beef Au Jus Gravy

$7.99
Beef Au Jus – Ready to Heat & Serve Savor the classic flavor loved throughout Rochester, Buffalo, and all of Western New York! Red Osier Beef Au Jus Gravy brings the slow-roasted richness and depth that make prime rib dinners a favorite across...
Read more

Out of stock

Red Osier Roquefort Peppercorn Sauce

Red Osier Roquefort Peppercorn Gourmet Steak Gravy

$7.99
Red Osier Roquefort Peppercorn Enjoy the rich, creamy flavor of Red Osier Roquefort Peppercorn Gourmet Steak Gravy. This sauce features tangy Roquefort blue cheese and cracked black pepper, delivering versatile, robust flavor loved by steak and prime rib fans across Rochester, Buffalo, and...
Read more

Out of stock

RJ's Gourmet Buffalo Wing Sauce

RJ's Gourmet Buffalo Wing Sauce – Mild

(9 Reviews)

$8.99
Heat Level: Mild
Read more

Out of stock

Sal's Sassy Sauce

Sal's Sassy Sauce – Mild

$6.99
Flavor: Mild
Read more

Out of stock

Sal's Hot Sassy Sauce

Sal's Sassy Sauce – Hot

$6.99
Flavor: Hot
Read more