***ATTENTION! Online Order Fulfillment Paused. Orders Placed 2/14 - 2/20 will start shipping 2/21.***

Shipping Simplified: $7.95 Flat Rate, Free $69+ or Free Delivery ($39+) in Monroe County, NY

Check Our Freebies List!

All Orders $69+

Cart

No products in the cart.

Return To Shop
Shopping cart (0)
Subtotal: $0.00

View cart

Cart $0.00
2 columns grid
3 columns grid
4 columns grid
List
More
Show

Out of stock

Fire Roasted Red Hot Sauce

High Desert Sauce Co. Fire Roasted Red Hot Sauce

$9.99
Fire Roasted Red Hot Sauce The savory heat of roasted Jalapeno, Habanero, Ghost Pepper, and Carolina Reaper boils devilishly over the flavorful base of tomato, garlic, and onion. Heat Level: Hot Ingredients: Distilled Vinegar, Fire Roasted Tomato, Fire Roasted Poblano, Fire Roasted Jalapeno,...
Read more

Out of stock

Historic Lynchburg Habanero Hot Sauce

Historic Lynchburg Habanero Hot Sauce

$8.99
Historic Lynchburg Habanero Hot Sauce Made with both Habanero and Jalapeno peppers and Jack Daniel’s Black Label Whiskey. Heat Rating: Hot 6oz
Read more

Out of stock

Historic Lynchburg Jalapeno Hot Sauce

Historic Lynchburg Jalapeno Hot Sauce

$5.99
Historic Lynchburg Jalapeno Hot Sauce This one is definitely hot, thanks to jalapenos, cayenne peppers, and spices. Made with real Jack Daniel’s! 6oz
Read more

Out of stock

Historic Lynchburg Jalapeno Pepper Ketchup

Historic Lynchburg Jalapeno Pepper Ketchup

$8.99
Jalapeno Pepper Ketchup A ketchup with a double kick, one of the heat from the red-ripened jalapenos, and the other from the genuine Jack Daniels Black Label Whiskey! Ingredients: Tomato Concentrate, Red Ripe Jalapeno Peppers, Distilled Vinegar, Corn Syrup, Salt, Spices, Garlic Powder,...
Read more

Out of stock

Hotter Than El Eco's Revenge Hot Sauce

Hotter Than El Eco’s Revenge Hot Sauce

$7.99
Eco’s Revenge Hot Sauce Hotter Than El’s verde-style hot sauce. Green Serrano peppers are blended with Jalapenos for a robust flavor. Heat Level: Mild Ingredients: Tomatillos (Tomatillos, Water, Citric Acid and Salt), Green Serrano Pepper Mash (Green Serrano Peppers, and Salt), Distilled Vinegar,...
Read more

Out of stock

HYCH Guajillo Mexican-Style Roasted Pepper Hot Sauce

HYCH Guajillo Mexican-Style Roasted Pepper Hot Sauce

(1 Review)

$9.99
Guajillo Mexican-Style Roasted Pepper Hot Sauce Jalapenos, cayenne, and guajillo peppers mix it up with honey, roasted onions, and tomatoes to bring you a fiesta in a bottle! Heat Level: Medium Ingredients: Water, Onions, non-GMO sunflower oil, Tomatoes, Guajillo peppers, Tomato paste, Garlic,...
Read more

Out of stock

HYCH Nashville Hot Chicken Hot Sauce

HYCH Nashville Hot Chicken Hot Sauce

$9.99
Nashville Hot Chicken Hot Sauce The perfect Nashville hot chicken sauce! Red jalapeno is combined with a dash of brown sugar and a secret spice blend. The result? A trip to Nashville for your taste buds! Heat Level: Hot Ingredients: Jalapeno, Water, Brown...
Read more

Out of stock

Jalapeno Olive Oil

Jalapeno Olive Oil

(6 Reviews)

$17.99
Jalapeno Olive Oil Our Jalapeno Olive Oil is infused with real jalapenos for a clean, natural heat that lifts every dish. No artificial or natural flavorings are added. The peppers themselves bring a bright, fresh spice that blends smoothly with premium olive oil....
Read more

Out of stock

Jersey Barnfire Black Garlic Bacon Hot Sauce

Jersey Barnfire Black Garlic Bacon Hot Sauce

$11.99
Black Garlic Bacon Hot Sauce Succulent hickory bacon flavor is combined with black garlic and red jalapeno for the ultimate hot sauce experience! Awards: 2024 Screaming Mimi Mimi – 3rd Place – Pepper Blend Mild Heat Level: Mild Ingredients: Water, apple cider vinegar,...
Read more

Out of stock

Jersey Barnfire Black Garlic Hot Sauce

Jersey Barnfire Black Garlic Hot Sauce

(1 Review)

$11.99
Jersey Barnfire Black Garlic Hot Sauce Takes the deep flavor of black garlic and melds it with the sweet heat flavor you know and love from Jersey Barnfire! Ingredients: Hot peppers (jalapeno, habanero), vinegar, water, tomatoes, sugar, onions, garlic, organic black garlic, salt,...
Read more

Out of stock

Jersey Barnfire Garden State Green Hot Sauce

Jersey Barnfire Garden State Green Hot Sauce

$9.99
Garden State Green Hot Sauce A traditional verde-style hot sauce. Loaded with jalapenos and tomatillos with a hint of lime and cilantro. Ingredients: Tomatillos, jalapenos, water, white vinegar, apple cider vinegar, cilantro, lime juice, onions, sugar, mixed green super hot pepper mash (mixed...
Read more

Out of stock

Jersey Barnfire Original Hot Sauce

Jersey Barnfire Original Hot Sauce

$8.99
Jersey Barnfire Original Hot Sauce A sweet, tangy and loaded with flavor that’ll keep you coming back for more! Versatile – use it on almost anything! Ingredients: Hot peppers (jalapeno, habanero), vinegar, water, tomatoes, sugar, onions, garlic, salt, spices, olive oil, herbs, xanthan...
Read more

Out of stock

Julz's Creations Reaper's Scythe - 1.7fl oz

Julz's Creations Reaper's Scythe Hot Sauce – 1.7oz

$3.99
Size: 1.7oz
Read more

Out of stock

Lucky Dog Red Label Hot Sauce

Lucky Dog Red Label Hot Sauce

(1 Review)

$9.99
Lucky Dog Red Label Hot Sauce Featuring a well-balanced blend of habanero, jalapeno, and serrano peppers & carrot, creating a sweet-heat balance. Ingredients: Cider Vinegar, Onion, Roasted Jalapeno, Water, Roasted Garlic, Carrot Juice, Chile Peppers, Sea Salt, Carrots, Cayenne Pepper, Agave, Lime Juice...
Read more

Out of stock

Mikey V's 512 Pot Sauce

Mikey V’s 512 Pot Sauce

$9.99
Mikey V’s Pot Sauce A medium hot sauce that is sure to please any palette. The peppers are roasted and blended with hemp seeds to create this greatness! Hemp contains 0.001% THC and WILL NOT cause a psychoactive effect, nor will this product cause...
Read more

Out of stock

Mikey V's Sam Sauce

Mikey V’s Sam Sauce

$10.99
Mikey V’s Sam Sauce A unique hot sauce made with 7-Pot Primo and Jalapeno peppers along with Japanese Black and Yuzu vinegars. Ingredients: Tomatillos, Apple Juice from Concentrate (Filtered water, Apple Juice concentrate, Ascorbic Acid [Vitamin C]),7-Pot Primo Peppers, Onions, Jalapeno Peppers, Fresh...
Read more

Out of stock

Palo Alto Firefighters Original Pepper Sauce

Palo Alto Firefighters Original Pepper Sauce

$9.99
Palo Alto Firefighters Original Hot Sauce A Scovie Award-winning hot sauce. A complex, full-flavored sauce that holds its own or plays well with others. Heat Level: Medium Ingredients: Red jalapeno peppers, water, distilled vinegar, sugar, paprika, spice, xanthan gum 8.5oz
Read more

Out of stock

Palo Alto Firefighters XX Habanero Pepper Sauce

Palo Alto Firefighters XX Habanero Pepper Sauce

$9.99
Palo Alto Firefighters XX Habanero Pepper Sauce Made by an actual retired firefighter from Palo Alto, this sauce is made with fresh jalapenos, habaneros, paprika and cumin, making it perfect for chili! Heat Level: Medium (hot if you have a low heat tolerance)....
Read more

Out of stock

PepperNutz Jalapeno Hot Sauce

PepperNutz Jalapeno Hot Sauce

(1 Review)

$6.99
PepperNutz Jalapeno Hot Sauce A traditional Mexican-style Jalapeno hot sauce with a slightly chunky texture and a robust Jalapeno essence. It has a touch of sweetness from a dash of sugar cane. Heat Level: Medium Ingredients: Vinegar, Jalapeno Peppers, Sugar, Salt, Garlic, Xanthan...
Read more

Out of stock

Puckerbutt Pepper Company Reaper Racha Hot Sauce

PuckerButt Pepper Company Reaper Racha Hot Sauce

$9.99
Reaper Racha Hot Sauce Puckerbutt’s spin on a traditional sriracha sauce is exactly what you’d expect – extremely hot but bursting with flavor! A tomato-based sauce filled with Carolina Reapers. Heat Level: Extremely Hot Ingredients: Red Habanero Pepper Mash (Red Habanero Peppers, Salt),...
Read more

Out of stock

Queen Majesty Jalapeno, Tequila & Lime Hot Sauce

Queen Majesty Jalapeño Tequila & Lime Hot Sauce

$10.99
Queen Majesty Jalapeño Tequila & Lime Can you think of a better trio? Winner of Screaming Mimi’s Gold Medal 2015 at the NYC Hot Sauce Expo. Heat Level: Medium Ingredients: White vinegar, jalapeño peppers, onions, apple cider vinegar with mother, lime juice, white...
Read more

Out of stock

Sale!
Rising Smoke Sauceworks Fire Starter Hot Sauce

Rising Smoke Sauceworks Fire Starter Hot Sauce

(1 Review)

Original price was: $9.99.Current price is: $5.00.
Fire Starter Hot Sauce Take a walk on the mild side with a tasty trifecta of fire-roasted jalapeños, garlic and tomatillos. Ingredients: Fire Roasted Jalapeño Peppers, Water, Vinegar, Tomatillos, Onion, Garlic, Salt, Spices. 5 fl oz
Read more

Out of stock

Seed Ranch Flavor Co. Smoked Jalapeno Hot Sauce

Seed Ranch Flavor Co. Smoked Jalapeno Hot Sauce

$9.99
Seed Ranch Flavor Co. Smoked Jalapeno Hot Sauce A great everyday table sauce. Simple, clean ingredients like carrots and dates without the extra sugar. Organic Ingredients, No GMO, Gluten-free, Vegan, No Sugar Added, Paleo Friendly. Ingredients: Organic chipotle peppers, organic vinegar, organic dates, organic carrots,...
Read more

Out of stock

The Spicy Shark Nurse Shark Jalapeno Hot Sauce

The Spicy Shark Nurse Shark Jalapeno Hot Sauce

$8.99
Nurse Shark Hot Sauce A green jalapeno sauce that has a mellow, smooth heat but huge flavor. Undertones of tomatillo, apple, and melon balance the heat from the jalapeno and poblano pepper for an approachable, but unforgettable taste. Heat Level: Mild Ingredients: Jalapeno Pepper,...
Read more