***ATTENTION! Online Order Fulfillment Paused. Orders Placed 2/14 - 2/20 will start shipping 2/21.***

Shipping Simplified: $7.95 Flat Rate, Free $69+ or Free Delivery ($39+) in Monroe County, NY

Check Our Freebies List!

All Orders $69+

Cart

No products in the cart.

Return To Shop
Shopping cart (0)
Subtotal: $0.00

View cart

Cart $0.00
2 columns grid
3 columns grid
4 columns grid
List
More
Show

In stock

Karma Sauce Buffalo Hot Sauce

Karma Sauce Buffalo Hot Sauce

(1 Review)

$7.99

Buffalo buffalo Buffalo buffalo buffalo buffalo Buffalo buffalo Hot Sauce

Buffalo 8 times in a row? Yes, it's technically grammatically correct.

This mild but extremely flavorful sauce is Karma Sauce's take on the Western New York classic. Your chicken wing game just leveled-up.

Heat Level: Mild Ingredients: Cayenne Pepper, apple cider vinegar, garlic, fig concentrate, tamarind, onion, ancho chile, salt, celery seed.

5oz

Add to cart

In stock

Smokey Karma Hot Sauce

Karma Sauce Smokey Karma Hot Sauce

(1 Review)

$6.99

Smokey Karma Hot Sauce

Chipotle chiles are added to the classic Karma Sauce butternut squash base to create a real game changer. Try it in a chicken wing dip! Heat Level: Mild Ingredients: red pepper, butternut squash, apple cider vinegar, onion, sweet potato, honey, garlic, salt, ground chipotle chile, ginger, orange peel. 5oz
Add to cart

In stock

Mikey V's Peach Habanero Delight Hot Sauce

Mikey V’s Peach Habanero Delight Hot Sauce

$7.99
Mikey V’s Peach Habanero Delight A tropical mix of mild peppers, red onion, and habaneros perfectly blended with peaches and pineapple for a naturally sweet, island flavor. Heat Level: Mild Ingredients: Sliced Peaches (peaches, peach juice, pear juice, natural flavor, ascorbic acid), White...
Add to cart

In stock

Queen Majesty Red Habanero & Black Coffee Hot Sauce

Queen Majesty Red Habanero & Black Coffee Hot Sauce

$9.99
Queen Majesty Red Habanero & Black Coffee This hot sauce perfectly balances an exciting flavor with a sensational heat. Queen Majesty’s hottest sauce. See it on Season 3 of the award-winning YouTube show Hot Ones. Heat Level: Hot Ingredients: Fair trade coffee-infused white...
Add to cart

In stock

Sale!
Rainier Foods The Essentials Seasoning

Rainier Foods The Essentials Seasoning

Original price was: $7.99.Current price is: $4.99.
The Essentials Seasoning Salt, Pepper, and Garlic. This epic trio are the essentials of most seasonings, and no one does it like Rainier Foods! Ingredients: Sea Salt (Including Red Alea Sea Salt), Garlic, Black Pepper, Organic Sunflower Oil. 8 oz
Add to cart

In stock

Sale!
Rising Smoke Sauceworks Synergy Hot Sauce

Rising Smoke Sauceworks Synergy Hot Sauce

Original price was: $10.99.Current price is: $7.99.
Synergy Hot Sauce A medium, sweet, and spicy Asian style hot sauce with mirin, tamari, and red jalapenos. Heat Level: Medium Ingredients: Mirin (fructose, sake, water, yeast extract, caramel, lactic acid, succine acid), Vinegar, Red Jalapeno Pepper Mash (peppers, vinegar), Roasted Red Bell...
Add to cart

In stock

Rocky's Nashville Style Hot Sauce

Rocky's Nashville Style Hot Sauce – 5oz

$9.99
Size: 5oz
Add to cart

In stock

Rocky's Taco Hot Sauce

Rocky's Taco Hot Sauce – 5oz

$9.99
Size: 5oz
Add to cart

In stock

Splintered Sauce Dirty Blues Hot Sauce

Splintered Sauce Dirty Blues Hot Sauce

$9.99
Dirty Blues Hot Sauce Dirty Blues hot sauce brings a unique twist, intertwining the fierce Carolina Reaper pepper with the “cool” sweetness of blueberries. You’ll experience an initial refreshing taste before the heat gently kicks in, providing a pleasant warmth that fades without...
Add to cart

In stock

Splintered Sauce Lu'Au Pohaku Hot Sauce

Splintered Sauce Lu’Au Pohaku Hot Sauce

$9.99
Lu’Au Pohaku Hot Sauce Winner of multiple awards, Lu’Au Pohaku is a hot sauce that fuses the tropical sweetness of pineapples with the powerful heat of the Carolina Reaper. It delivers a sweet, melodic flavor with just enough heat to improve the groove,...
Add to cart

In stock

Sale!
Suave Sauce Bomb-Ass Hot Sauce

Suavé Sauce Bomb-Ass Hot Sauce

Original price was: $10.99.Current price is: $9.99.
Bomb-Ass Hot Sauce A little goes a long way! Suavé Sauce’s entry into the “pepper” hot sauce realm is a wickedly hot mashup of Ghost Peppers combined with peaches and pineapples. Contains Soy, Fish 5 fl oz
Add to cart

Only 1 left in stock

Sale!
Anchor Bar Mild Buffalo Wing Sauce

Anchor Bar Buffalo Wing Sauce – Mild

Original price was: $6.99.Current price is: $5.99.
Flavor: Mild
Add to cart

Only 1 left in stock

Sale!
Anchor Bar Medium Buffalo Wing Sauce

Anchor Bar Buffalo Wing Sauce – Medium

Original price was: $6.99.Current price is: $5.99.
Flavor: Medium
Add to cart

Only 1 left in stock

Sale!
Anchor Bar Garlic Parmesan Wing Sauce

Anchor Bar Buffalo Wing Sauce – Garlic Parmesan

Original price was: $6.99.Current price is: $5.99.
Flavor: Garlic Parmesan
Add to cart

Only 1 left in stock

Sale!
Anchor Bar Spicy BBQ Wing Sauce

Anchor Bar Buffalo Wing Sauce – Spicy BBQ

Original price was: $6.99.Current price is: $5.99.
Flavor: Spicy BBQ
Add to cart

Only 1 left in stock

Born to Hula Smokin' Pineapple Hot Sauce

Born to Hula Smokin’ Pineapple Hot Sauce

$7.99
Born to Hula Smokin’ Pineapple “Tropical Island Flavors with Cannibalistic Heat!” Made with fatalii and smoked habanero peppers. Heat Level: Hot Ingredients: Fresh Pineapple, Distilled Vinegar, Fatalii Pepper, Smoked Habanero Pepper, Onion Powder, Sea Salt, Lime Juice 5 fl oz
Add to cart

Only 1 left in stock

Sale!
Burning Asphalt Beer Can Rotisserie Seasoning

Burning Asphalt Beer Can & Rotisserie Seasoning

Original price was: $8.99.Current price is: $6.99.
Beer Can & Rotisserie Seasoning This great rub from Burning Asphalt is wonderful as a seasoning for any food cooked on a rotisserie. Ingredients: Sugar, Salt, Black Pepper, Paprika, Maltodextrin, Garlic, Onion, Calcium Stearate, Cayenne, Paprika Oleoresin. Gluten-Free Kosher 7oz
Add to cart

Only 1 left in stock

Chef James' Bourbon Meat Sauce

Chef James’ Bourbon Meat Sauce

(1 Review)

$8.99
Chef James’ Bourbon Meat Sauce Take a piece of Lovin’ Cup home with you! Sous Chef James’s signature meat hot sauce recipe takes a unique spin with the addition of Iron Smoke Distillery Bourbon Whiskey! Simmer and serve on Medium Low. Like it...
Add to cart

Only 1 left in stock

Guglielmo's Pizza Sauce

Guglielmo’s Pizza Sauce

$7.99
Guglielmo’s Pizza Sauce A unique pizza sauce that’s sweetened with honey and made full of love from owner Paul Guglielmo. Net. Wt. 16oz (453g)
Add to cart

Only 1 left in stock

Sale!
HCO + Bee Dolce Hot Crispy Honey

HCO + Bee Dolce Hot Crispy Honey

Original price was: $12.99.Current price is: $9.99.
HCO Honey Experience sweet heat in every bite with this collaboration between Hot Crispy Oil and Bee Dolce Honey. Made with U.S. Grade A honey and fried garlic, perfect for pizza, meats, veggies, and dips. Ingredients: Dark Wildflower Honey, Fried Garlic, Avocado Oil,...
Add to cart

Only 1 left in stock

Hot Ones Los Calientes Rojo Hot Sauce

Hot Ones Los Calientes Hot Sauce – Rojo

$12.00
Flavor: Rojo
Add to cart

Only 1 left in stock

Reaper's Scythe Hot Sauce

Julz's Creations Reaper's Scythe Hot Sauce – 5oz

$9.99
Size: 5oz
Add to cart

Only 1 left in stock

Sale!
Mikey V's Crack of Don

Mikey V’s Crack of Don Hot Sauce

Original price was: $9.99.Current price is: $7.99.
Crack of Don Hot Sauce Created to go a whole bunch of different foods, this great sauce uses yellow fatailii pepper and pineapple to make a hot sauce that bursts with flavor! Heat Level: Hot 5 fl oz
Add to cart

Only 1 left in stock

Papa Joe's Pasta Sauce

Papa Joe’s Pasta Sauce

$6.99
Papa Joe’s Italian Eatery Pasta Sauce Savor authentic Italian flavor with Papa Joe’s Pasta Sauce, a Rochester, NY area favorite known for hearty, generous portions and traditional recipes. This 24-ounce jar features a delicious, nutritious blend of premium tomatoes and classic herbs, perfect...
Add to cart