***ATTENTION! Online Order Fulfillment Paused. Orders Placed 2/14 - 2/20 will start shipping 2/21.***

Shipping Simplified: $7.95 Flat Rate, Free $69+ or Free Delivery ($39+) in Monroe County, NY

Check Our Freebies List!

All Orders $69+

Cart

No products in the cart.

Return To Shop
Shopping cart (0)
Subtotal: $0.00

View cart

Cart $0.00
2 columns grid
3 columns grid
4 columns grid
List
More
Show

Out of stock

Jersey Barnfire Indian Summer Hot Sauce

Jersey Barnfire Indian Summer Hot Sauce

$9.99
Indian Summer Hot Sauce This hot sauce won the Grand World Champion Screaming Mimi at the NYC Hot Sauce Expo! It’s a unique twist on a spicy Caribbean-style hot sauce. Awards: 2024 Screaming Mimi Mimi – 3rd Place – Caribbean Style Heat Level:...
Read more

Out of stock

Jersey Barnfire Original Hot Sauce

Jersey Barnfire Original Hot Sauce

$8.99
Jersey Barnfire Original Hot Sauce A sweet, tangy and loaded with flavor that’ll keep you coming back for more! Versatile – use it on almost anything! Ingredients: Hot peppers (jalapeno, habanero), vinegar, water, tomatoes, sugar, onions, garlic, salt, spices, olive oil, herbs, xanthan...
Read more

Out of stock

Jersey Barnfire Roasted Peach Habanero Hot Sauce

Jersey Barnfire Roasted Peach Habanero Hot Sauce

$9.99
Roasted Peach Habanero Hot Sauce Fresh peaches combined with habaneros make this seasonal sweet heat treat sing on chicken, pork, fish and more! Heat Level: Medium Ingredients: Peaches, white vinegar, water, sugar, habanero pepper, brown sugar, spices, salt, xanthan gum. 5oz
Read more

Out of stock

Jersey Barnfire Salt & Pepper Ketchup

Jersey Barnfire Salt & Pepper Ketchup

$9.99
Jersey Barnfire Salt & Pepper Ketchup All things you’d expect from a Jersey Diner! A scratch ketchup pumped up with salt, pepper, and habaneros. Ingredients: Vinegar, water, sugar, tomato paste (tomatoes, citric acid), Habanero mash (habanero peppers, vinegar), salt, spices, xanthan gum
Read more

Out of stock

Jersey Barnfire Smoked Ghost Taco Hot Sauce

Jersey Barnfire Smoked Ghost Taco Hot Sauce

$9.99
Smoked Ghost Taco Hot Sauce This hot sauce combines smoked ghost peppers and classic taco seasoning to create the perfect blend of intense, smokey heat. Heat Level: Very Hot 5oz
Read more

Out of stock

Jersey Barnfire Strawberry Scorpion Hot Sauce

Jersey Barnfire Strawberry Scorpion Hot Sauce

(1 Review)

$9.99
Jersey Barnfire Strawberry Scorpion Hot Sauce Scorching hot Moruga Scorpion Peppers are mixed with real, fresh strawberries to take the term “sweet heat” to a whole new level! Ingredients: Strawberries, water, sugar, rice vinegar, white vinegar, scorpion peppers, salt, xanthan gum. 5oz
Read more

Out of stock

Joon Pistachios - Original Salted

Joon Pistachios – Original Salted

$7.99
Flavor: Original Salted
Read more

Out of stock

Joon Pistachios - Dill Pickle

Joon Pistachios – Dill Pickle

$7.99
Flavor: Dill Pickle
Read more

Out of stock

Joon Pistachios - Salt & Pepper

Joon Pistachios – Salt & Pepper

$7.99
Flavor: Salt & Pepper
Read more

Out of stock

Julz's Creations Reaper's Scythe - 1.7fl oz

Julz's Creations Reaper's Scythe Hot Sauce – 1.7oz

$3.99
Size: 1.7oz
Read more

Out of stock

Sale!
Karma Sauce 3-Pack: Good, Bad, and Extreme

Karma Sauce 3 Pack – Good, Bad & Extreme

Original price was: $26.97.Current price is: $24.97.
Karma Sauce 3 Pack – Good, Bad & Extreme Get one of each! Good Karma Bad Karma Extreme Karma
Read more

Out of stock

Good Karma Hot Sauce

Karma Sauce Good Karma Hot Sauce

(2 Reviews)

$6.99

Good Karma Hot Sauce

Good Karma is way better than good...it's incredible! A chunky mix of habaneros and butternut squash makes this the perfect mild hot sauce alternative. Heat Level: Mild Ingredients: red pepper, butternut squash, apple cider vinegar, onion, sweet potato, honey, garlic, salt, ginger. 5oz
Read more

Out of stock

Karma Sauce Instant Karma Seasoning

Karma Sauce Instant Karma Seasoning

$6.99
Karma Sauce Instant Karma Seasoning The signature rub of the Karma family – a one-of-a-kind blend of chile, coriander, garlic and exotic flavors. Use liberally every now and zen. Ingredients: sea salt, onion, ground chile, garlic, coriander, cumin, black pepper, ginger, cinnamon, nutmeg, star...
Read more

Out of stock

Karma Sauce Jerk Me Around Seasoning

Karma Sauce Jerk Me Around Seasoning

$6.99
Karma Sauce Jerk Me Around Seasoning Tour the flavors of the Caribbean with chile, mango, allspice and other tropical spice inspirations. Boost chicken and other meats and recipes with a dash of island fire! Ingredients: sea salt, evaporated cane juice, onion, ground chile, green...
Read more

Out of stock

Sale!
Karma Sauce Smokey Trio: Contains Smokey Karma, Extreme Karma, and Extreme Smokey Karma

Karma Sauce Smokey Trio

(1 Review)

Original price was: $30.97.Current price is: $27.97.
Karma Sauce Smokey Trio Grab this bundle putting together Smokey, Extreme, and the brand new Flower City Flavor Company exclusive Extreme Smokey Karma Sauce so you can try Karma’s amazing original flavors with their brand new mash-up.
Read more

Out of stock

Kill Sauce Fresno Hot Sauce

Kill Sauce Fresno Hot Sauce

(2 Reviews)

$8.99
Kill Sauce Fresno Hot Sauce The perfect breakfast hot sauce. Sweet and vibrant Fresno peppers are the star of the show. Heat Level: Mild 5oz
Read more

Out of stock

Kill Sauce Ghost Hot Sauce

Kill Sauce Ghost Hot Sauce

(3 Reviews)

$8.99
Kill Sauce Ghost Hot Sauce Blackberries and raspberries mix with spicy Ghost peppers for a fantastic hot sauce that can be used on a variety of different foods. Heat Level: Hot 5oz
Read more

Out of stock

Klowns on Fire I Scream Klown Hot Sauce

Klowns on Fire I Scream Klown Hot Sauce

$11.99
I Scream Klown Hot Sauce The best hot sauce for ice cream you can buy! High-end chocolate and raspberries combine with the extreme heat of the Carolina Reaper! Heat Level: Very Hot Ingredients: Raspberries, Dark Chocolate, Lemon Juice, Lime Juice, Honey, Carolina Reaper,...
Read more

Out of stock

Klowns on Fire Klownfische Seafood Sauce

Klowns on Fire Klownfische Seafood Sauce

$11.99
Klownfische Seafood Sauce Klownfische is a seafood sauce with a horseradish and wasabi kick that is  subtle enough to complement any seafood or other proteins. Heat Level: Medium Ingredients: Water, Alfonso Mango Puree, Wasabi Powder, Sweet Cream Solids, Apple Cider Vinegar, Less Than...
Read more

Out of stock

Lemon Olive Oil

Lemon Olive Oil

(4 Reviews)

$17.99
Lemon Olive Oil Our Lemon Olive Oil blends premium olive oil with the crisp, refreshing flavor of real lemons. No artificial or natural flavorings are added. The fruit itself creates a bright, aromatic profile that brings lift and acidity to a wide range...
Read more

Out of stock

Lucky Dog Heat's a Peach Hot Sauce

Lucky Dog Heat’s a Peach Hot Sauce

(1 Review)

$8.99
Lucky Dog Heat’s a Peach Hot Sauce A Barbados-style sauce created by combining Trinidad Scorpion peppers with peaches, roasted garlic, pears and spices. 5oz
Read more

Out of stock

Lucky Dog Hell Hound Hot Sauce

Lucky Dog Hell Hound Hot Sauce

(1 Review)

$11.99
Lucky Dog Hell Hound Hot Sauce Features the searing heat of the Carolina Reaper, along with fire-roasted peppers, mango, tamarind & roasted garlic. 5oz
Read more

Out of stock

Lucky Dog Red Label Hot Sauce

Lucky Dog Red Label Hot Sauce

(1 Review)

$9.99
Lucky Dog Red Label Hot Sauce Featuring a well-balanced blend of habanero, jalapeno, and serrano peppers & carrot, creating a sweet-heat balance. Ingredients: Cider Vinegar, Onion, Roasted Jalapeno, Water, Roasted Garlic, Carrot Juice, Chile Peppers, Sea Salt, Carrots, Cayenne Pepper, Agave, Lime Juice...
Read more

Out of stock

Lucky Dog Year of the Dog Hot Sauce

Lucky Dog Year of the Dog Hot Sauce

$9.99
Year of the Dog Hot Sauce This fantastic hot sauce was featured on Season 9 of the hit YouTube show Hot Ones! Its pineapple overtones blend seamlessly with red Thai chiles. Heat Level: Hot Ingredients: Pineapple, rice vinegar, onion, roasted garlic, honey, dried...
Read more