***ATTENTION! Online orders will be unavailable for an extended time. Please visit us at our brick-and-mortar Pharmacy Locations.***

Shipping Simplified: $7.95 Flat Rate, Free $69+ or Free Delivery ($39+) in Monroe County, NY

Check Our Freebies List!

All Orders $69+

Cart
Shopping cart (10)
Subtotal: $85.92

View cart

Cart $85.92
2 columns grid
3 columns grid
4 columns grid
List
More
Show

Out of stock

Death By Chili Sauce - Original - 5oz

Death by Chili Sauce – 5oz

$7.99
Size: 5oz
Read more

Out of stock

PepperNutz Mango Hab Hot Sauce

PepperNutz Mango Hab Hot Sauce

(7 Reviews)

$6.99
PepperNutz Mango Hab Hot Sauce An all-natural small batch hot sauce with a smooth blend of fresh mangoes and Habanero peppers. Our best selling hot sauce from PepperNutz and best selling mango habanero style. 5oz
Read more

Out of stock

Death By Chili Sauce - Original - 12oz

Death by Chili Sauce – 12oz

$11.99
Size: 12oz
Read more

Out of stock

Death By Chili Sauce - Extra Hot

Death By Chili Sauce – Extra Hot

(4 Reviews)

$7.99
Death By Chili Sauce – Extra Hot For true heatseekers! Not over-the-top hot, but just enough to keep that kick in your mouth and on your tongue long after consumption. Lucky for you, this is one of the best tasting hot sauces you’ll...
Read more

Out of stock

Death By Chili Sauce - Mild- 12oz

Death By Chili Sauce - Mild – 12oz

$11.99
Size: 12oz
Read more

Out of stock

Bill Gray's Hot Sauce

Bill Gray’s Hot Sauce

(4 Reviews)

$7.99
Bill Gray’s Hot Sauce More than just a condiment, Bill Gray’s Hot Sauce is an authentic taste of Rochester’s history. Since 1938, Bill Gray’s has been a local institution renowned for serving its legendary “World’s Greatest Cheeseburger” and “Great Plates”, comfort food classics...
Read more

Out of stock

Karma Sauce Huhu Pina Hot Sauce

Karma Sauce Huhu Pina Hot Sauce

(1 Review)

$6.99

Huhu Pina

This hot sauce will excite your tongue with not just pineapple but Korean Gochugaru and hints of ginger, agave and marjoram. 2020 Fiery Food Challenge Winner - Exotic Hot Sauce & Latin Hot Sauce Heat Level: Mild Ingredients: Pineapple, Smoked Yellow Bell Pepper, Apple Cider Vinegar, Apple, Lime Juice, Agave Nectar, Water, Garlic, Gochugaru Pepper, Habanero Pepper, Salt, Cumin, Ginger, Marjoram, Celery Seed. 5 fl oz
Read more

Out of stock

PepperNutz Pineapple Hot Sauce

PepperNutz Pineapple Hot Sauce

(2 Reviews)

$6.99
PepperNutz Pineapple Hot Sauce An all-natural hot sauce with a flavorful blast of pineapple and oranges with hints of ginger, garlic, onions and honey. 5oz
Read more

Out of stock

PepperNutz ROC'n Reaper Hot Sauce

PepperNutz ROC’n Reaper Hot Sauce

(3 Reviews)

$7.99
PepperNutz ROC’n Reaper Hot Sauce An all-natural small batch hot sauce with a tomato base and featuring the crazy heat of the Carolina Reaper pepper. 5 fl oz
Read more

Out of stock

PepperNutz Mystic Pizza Hot Sauce

PepperNutz Mystic Pizza Hot Sauce

(2 Reviews)

$6.99
Mystic Pizza Hot Sauce This sauce is all the essence of an Italian kitchen captured in a bottle! Tastes just like a spicy pizza, without the dough or tomatoes! Heat Level: Medium Ingredients: Louisiana Hot Sauce (Aged Red Peppers, Distilled Vinegar, Salt and...
Read more

Out of stock

PepperNutz Caribbean Rum Hot Sauce

PepperNutz Caribbean Rum Hot Sauce

(2 Reviews)

$6.99
PepperNutz Caribbean Rum Hot Sauce An all-natural small batch hot sauce with a sweet essence and chunkier texture from the light blending of Cayenne and Peri Peri peppers, Caribbean fruits, honey, raisins, and most importantly… DARK RUM! Ingredients: Pineapple, Apple Cider Vinegar, Dark...
Read more

Out of stock

Sale!
Karma Sauce Ashes 2 Ashes Hot Sauce

Karma Sauce Ashes-2-Ashes Hot Sauce

(1 Review)

Original price was: $13.99.Current price is: $10.00.

Ashes-2-Ashes Hot Sauce

This scorcher will turn your mouth into dust! Your face will explode from the lava-like heat level that comes from the 7 Pot Primo peppers.
Heat Level: Extremely Hot
Ingredients: Super hot red pepper, apple cider vinegar, organic sugar, fresh lime juice, salt, garlic, chipotle chile
5oz
Read more

Out of stock

Death By Chili Sauce - Mild- 5oz

Death By Chili Sauce - Mild – 5oz

$7.99
Size: 5oz
Read more

Out of stock

Red Catastrophe Hot Sauce

Red Catastrophe Hot Sauce

(1 Review)

$8.99
Red Catastrophe Hot Sauce Sweet, hot & sassy and this kitty will keep you purring all night. Made with real Red Cat wine from Hazlitt 1852 Vineyards located in the Finger Lakes in beautiful upstate New York. Red Savina Habaneros and garlic duke...
Read more

Out of stock

PepperNutz Ghost Pepper Hot Sauce

PepperNutz Ghost Pepper Hot Sauce

(3 Reviews)

$6.99
PepperNutz Ghost Pepper Hot Sauce An all-natural small batch hot sauce with a tomato base and blend of Ghost, Peri Peri and Cayenne peppers. 5oz
Read more

Out of stock

PepperNutz Banana Hot Sauce

PepperNutz Banana Hot Sauce

(1 Review)

$6.99
PepperNutz Banana Hot Sauce An all-natural small batch hot sauce with a unique blend of smoked peppers (Chipotle and Habanero), bananas, and rum. 5oz
Read more

Out of stock

Sale!
Karma Sauce Smokey Trio: Contains Smokey Karma, Extreme Karma, and Extreme Smokey Karma

Karma Sauce Smokey Trio

(1 Review)

Original price was: $30.97.Current price is: $27.97.
Karma Sauce Smokey Trio Grab this bundle putting together Smokey, Extreme, and the brand new Flower City Flavor Company exclusive Extreme Smokey Karma Sauce so you can try Karma’s amazing original flavors with their brand new mash-up.
Read more

Out of stock

Sale!
Peppernutz 6-Pack

PepperNutz 6-Pack

Original price was: $41.94.Current price is: $35.94.
Contains: Banana Caribbean Rum Ghost Pepper Mango Hab Pineapple ROC’n Reaper
Read more

Out of stock

PepperNutz Carolina Gold Hot Sauce

PepperNutz Carolina Gold Hot Sauce

(2 Reviews)

$7.99
PepperNutz Carolina Gold Inspired by the golden sauces of the Carolinas, PepperNutz’s Carolina Gold is semi-sweet, tangy, and packs a bite from the Habanero and Cayenne peppers. Ingredients: Yellow Mustard, Water, Onion, Red Wine Vinegar, Habanero Pepper, Brown Sugar, Ground Turmeric, Cayenne Pepper, Salt,...
Read more

Out of stock

Sale!
Karma Sauce 3-Pack: Good, Bad, and Extreme

Karma Sauce 3 Pack – Good, Bad & Extreme

Original price was: $26.97.Current price is: $24.97.
Karma Sauce 3 Pack – Good, Bad & Extreme Get one of each! Good Karma Bad Karma Extreme Karma
Read more

Out of stock

PepperNutz Jalapeno Hot Sauce

PepperNutz Jalapeno Hot Sauce

(1 Review)

$6.99
PepperNutz Jalapeno Hot Sauce A traditional Mexican-style Jalapeno hot sauce with a slightly chucky texture and a robust Jalapeno essence. It has a touch of sweetness from a dash of sugar cane. Heat Level: Medium Ingredients: Vinegar, Jalapeno Peppers, Sugar, Salt, Garlic, Xanthan...
Read more

Out of stock

PepperNutz Orange'gasm Hot Sauce

PepperNutz Orange’gasm Hot Sauce

(2 Reviews)

$6.99
PepperNutz Orange’gasm Hot Sauce A blend of carrots and orange Habanero peppers together with a great combination of fresh juices, veggies, agave nectar and select spices. Heat Level: Hot Ingredients: Water, Carrots, Agave Nectar, Onions, Habanero Peppers, Vinegar, Lime Juice, Garlic, Citric Acid,...
Read more

Out of stock

PepperNutz Roasted Red Pepper Hot Sauce

PepperNutz Roasted Red Pepper Hot Sauce

$7.99
Roasted Red Pepper Arrabbiata Hot Sauce “Arrabbiata” translates to “angry sauce” in Italian, but this hot sauce will make you anything but angry. You’ll be screaming for joy because this is one of our favorite hot sauces EVER and we are sure you...
Read more

Out of stock

PepperNutz Taco Caliente Hot Sauce

PepperNutz Taco Caliente Hot Sauce

(1 Review)

$6.99
PepperNutz Taco Caliente Hot Sauce This hot sauce has all the amazing flavors as PepperNutz’s Taco Templado, but with jacked up heat thanks to the addition of the Bird’s Eye Chili. Heat Level: Very Hot Ingredients: Aged Red Peppers, Distilled Vinegar, Salt, Spices,...
Read more