***ATTENTION! Online orders will be unavailable for an extended time. Please visit us at our brick-and-mortar Pharmacy Locations.***

Shipping Simplified: $7.95 Flat Rate, Free $69+ or Free Delivery ($39+) in Monroe County, NY

Check Our Freebies List!

All Orders $69+

Show

Out of stock

Fat Cat Cat in Heat Hot Sauce

Fat Cat Cat in Heat Hot Sauce

(1 Review)

$8.99
Fat Cat Cat in Heat Hot Sauce A sultry, scorching, smoky combination of ghost peppers, habaneros, chipotles, roasted tomatoes and more — with an ever-increasing heat level that lingers long in the mouth. Kick up your sandwiches, eggs, BBQ, stews and chili with...
Read more

Out of stock

Karma Sauce Funken Hot Yellow Moruga Hot Sauce

Out of stock

Puckerbutt Pepper Company Reaper Racha Hot Sauce

PuckerButt Pepper Company Reaper Racha Hot Sauce

$9.99
Reaper Racha Hot Sauce Puckerbutt’s spin on a traditional sriracha sauce is exactly what you’d expect – extremely hot but bursting with flavor! A tomato-based sauce filled with Carolina Reapers. Heat Level: Extremely Hot Ingredients: Red Habanero Pepper Mash (Red Habanero Peppers, Salt),...
Read more

Out of stock

Chocolate Plague Hot Sauce

Puckerbutt Pepper Company Chocolate Plague Hot Sauce

$14.99
Chocolate Plague Hot Sauce The star of this insanely hot creation, the Chocolate Bhutlah Pepper, is a hybrid of the Chocolate Douglah and Ghost pepper. This sauce was featured on Season 9 of the hit show Hot Ones. Heat Level: Extremely Hot Ingredients:...
Read more

Out of stock

Puckerbutt Pepper Company Gator Hot Sauce

Puckerbutt Pepper Company Gator Hot Sauce

$14.99
Gator Hot Sauce Containing Ed Currie’s legendary Pepper X pepper, this is the perfect hot sauce for those who can take the heat! Starts florally, ends fiery! Heat Level: Extremely Hot Ingredients: Pepper X Pepper Mash (Pepper X Peppers and Vinegar), Distilled Vinegar,...
Read more

Out of stock

Puckerbutt Pepper Company Voodoo Prince Death Mamba Hot Sauce

Puckerbutt Pepper Company Voodoo Prince Death Mamba Hot Sauce

(1 Review)

$8.99
Voodoo Prince Death Mamba Hot Sauce This sauce is a dark and sinister cocktail of spices and the vicious ghost pepper. Great on burgers and ribs. Heat Level: Extremely Hot 5oz
Read more

Out of stock

Puckerbutt Pepper Company The Reaper Hot Sauce

Puckerbutt Pepper Company The Reaper Hot Sauce

$14.99
The Reaper Hot Sauce The Carolina Reaper sauce that started it all from Smokin’ Ed Currie! Reapers and vinegar – that’s it – adding a clean heat to any meal. Heat Level: Extremely Hot Ingredients: Carolina Reaper® pepper and vinegar. 70% Carolina Reaper...
Read more

Out of stock

Puckerbutt Pepper Company Reaper Squeezin's Hot Sauce

Puckerbutt Pepper Company Reaper Squeezins Hot Sauce

(1 Review)

$14.99
Reaper Squeezins Hot Sauce Puckerbutt’s hottest sauce! Using all-natural ingredients, each bottle is crafted with the world’s hottest pepper, Puckerbutt owner Smokin’ Ed Currie’s Carolina Reaper. Heat Level: Extremely Hot Ingredients: Carolina Reaper peppers and vinegar. Made of 92% peppers. 5oz
Read more

Out of stock

Mikey V's Reaper Unleashed Hot Sauce

Mikey V’s Reaper Unleashed Hot Sauce

$11.99
Mikey V’s Reaper Unleashed Hot Sauce A hot sauce for those who want lots of flavor with the extreme heat. It will satisfy even the pickiest chili heads with its unique flavor. Ingredients: Tomatoes, white vinegar, water, white onion, fresh garlic, Carolina Reaper peppers,...
Read more

Out of stock

Mikey V's E.A.F.O. Hot Sauce

Mikey V’s E.A.F.O. Hot Sauce

$19.99
Mikey V’s E.A.F.O. Hot Sauce Mikey V’s hottest sauce to date and this one is a scorcher. The ultimate combination of flavor and insane heat. This hot sauce is 80% peppers by weight. This one certainly earns the “Extremely Hot” Heat Level rating....
Read more

Out of stock

Blair's Mega Death Sauce with Liquid Rage Hot Sauce

Blair’s Mega Death Sauce with Liquid Rage

$11.99
Blair’s Mega Death Sauce with Liquid Rage This hot sauce has 550,000 Scoville heat units of merciless intensity. Molasses hits your taste buds before an intense mix of cayenne, chipotle, and habanero peppers scorches your tongue. While this is a 10 out of...
Read more

Out of stock

Torchbearer Sauces Slaughter Hot Sauce

Torchbearer Sauces Slaughter Hot Sauce

$9.99
Slaughter Hot Sauce For those who love a real slow burn hot sauce. With a sweet first impression, the heat creeps up later! Ingredients: Habenero Peppers, Mandarin Oranges, Carrots, Onions, Tomatoes, Vinegar, Garlic, Sugar, and other all-natural spices.
Read more

Out of stock

Hellfire Kranked Hot Sauce

Hellfire Kranked Hot Sauce

$19.99
Kranked Hot Sauce A true scorcher that appeared on the hit YouTube show Hot Ones Season 16 in the #9 position! A Carolina Reaper sauce loaded with black garlic and spices. Awards: 2024 Screaming Mimi – 2nd Place – Reaper, 2024 Screaming Mimi...
Read more

Out of stock

PepperNutz Atomic Louisiana Hot Sauce

PepperNutz Atomic Louisiana Hot Sauce

$7.99
PepperNutz Atomic Louisiana Hot Sauce Get the milk ready. This is PepperNutz’s most intense hot sauce, made with 3 million Scoville unit chile extract. Use with extreme caution! Heat Level: Extremely Hot Ingredients: Aged Red Peppers, Vinegar, Chili Extract, Salt, and Xanthan Gum...
Read more

Out of stock

Torchbearer Sauces Ultimate Annihilation Hot Sauce

Torchbearer Sauces Ultimate Annihilation Hot Sauce

$15.99
Ultimate Annihilation Hot Sauce This is NOT an extract sauce – even though it may feel like it. The Annihilation has been called! Ingredients: Bhut Jolokia, Chocolate Habanero Peppers, Carrots, Mandarin Oranges, Tomatoes, Vinegar, Garlic, Sugar, and other all-natural spices.
Read more

Extremely Hot Hot Sauce — FAQ

These are the hottest sauces in the world, made for chili warriors and spice daredevils. Use these FAQs to handle them safely and enjoy responsibly.

What are the hottest peppers found in extremely hot sauces? Carolina Reaper, Trinidad Moruga Scorpion, and Pepper X are common, all exceeding 1,500,000 SHU.

How should I handle extremely hot hot sauce safely? Use gloves when handling, avoid touching your face, and start with just a drop. Wash hands thoroughly.

Is extremely hot hot sauce meant for cooking or challenges? Both! Use for heat challenges or as a fiery ingredient, but always use sparingly.

Are there health risks with extremely hot hot sauce? Extremely spicy sauces can irritate the skin or the digestive system; always consume them in moderation.

What are some foods to try with extremely hot hot sauce? Add carefully to wings, tacos, chili, or try a “spice dare”—these are sauces for true chili aficionados!