***ATTENTION! Online Order Fulfillment Paused. Orders Placed 2/14 - 2/20 will start shipping 2/21.***

Shipping Simplified: $7.95 Flat Rate, Free $69+ or Free Delivery ($39+) in Monroe County, NY

Check Our Freebies List!

All Orders $69+

Cart

No products in the cart.

Return To Shop
Shopping cart (0)
Subtotal: $0.00

View cart

Cart $0.00
2 columns grid
3 columns grid
4 columns grid
List
More
Show

In stock

Feeburgers Meat Hot Sauce

Feeburgers Meat Hot Sauce

(1 Review)

$8.99
Feeburgers Meat Hot Sauce Feeburger’s Original Hot Sauce with Beef is for hamburgers, cheeseburgers, home fries, macaroni salad, and just about anything! Ingredients: Ground Beef, Ketchup (Tomato Concentrate, Distilled Vinegar, High Fructose Corn Syrup, Corn Syrup, Salt, Spice, Onion Powder, Natural Flavoring), Hot...
Add to cart

In stock

Karma Sauce Huhu Diablo Hot Sauce

Karma Sauce Huhu Diablo Hot Sauce

(1 Review)

$8.99

Huhu Diablo

The extreme heat version of Karma Sauce's Huhu Pina. The 7 Pot Primo peppers will leave your mouth hotter than a Hawaiian volcano, all while still giving you the strong flavor of pineapple you know from the original. Heat Level: Very Hot Ingredients: Pineapple, Smoked Yellow Bell Pepper, Apple Cider Vinegar, Apple, Lime Juice, Agave Nectar, Water, Garlic, 7 Pot Primo Pepper, Salt, Cumin, Ginger, Marjoram, Celery Seed. 5oz
Add to cart

In stock

RJ's Hot Buffalo Wing Sauce

RJ's Gourmet Buffalo Wing Sauce – Hot

(9 Reviews)

$8.99
Heat Level: Hot
Add to cart

In stock

Sale!
Karma Sauce Ashes 2 Ashes Hot Sauce

Karma Sauce Ashes-2-Ashes Hot Sauce

(1 Review)

Original price was: $13.99.Current price is: $10.00.

Ashes-2-Ashes Hot Sauce

This scorcher will turn your mouth into dust! Your face will explode from the lava-like heat level that comes from the 7 Pot Primo peppers.
Heat Level: Extremely Hot
Ingredients: Super hot red pepper, apple cider vinegar, organic sugar, fresh lime juice, salt, garlic, chipotle chile
5oz
Add to cart

In stock

Sale!
Karma Sauce Burn After Eating Hot Sauce

Karma Sauce Burn After Eating Hot Sauce

(3 Reviews)

Original price was: $15.99.Current price is: $10.00.

Burn After Eating Hot Sauce

Karma Sauce's hottest sauce yet! Featured on the hit YouTube show "Hot Ones" Season 10. A hot sauce you don't eat...you survive! Heat Level: Extremely Hot Scoville units: 669,000 Ingredients: Brutally hot peppers, white vinegar, garlic, salt, ajwain seed, amchoor, hing powder (rice flour, gum arabic, asafoetida, turmeric), ginger extract. 5oz
Add to cart

In stock

Karma Sauce Funken Hot Yellow Moruga Hot Sauce

Karma Sauce Funken Hot Sauce – Yellow Moruga

$10.99
Flavor: Yellow Moruga
Add to cart

In stock

Karma Sauce Huhu Pina Hot Sauce

Karma Sauce Huhu Pina Hot Sauce

(1 Review)

$6.99

Huhu Pina

This hot sauce will excite your tongue with not just pineapple but Korean Gochugaru and hints of ginger, agave and marjoram. 2020 Fiery Food Challenge Winner - Exotic Hot Sauce & Latin Hot Sauce Heat Level: Mild Ingredients: Pineapple, Smoked Yellow Bell Pepper, Apple Cider Vinegar, Apple, Lime Juice, Agave Nectar, Water, Garlic, Gochugaru Pepper, Habanero Pepper, Salt, Cumin, Ginger, Marjoram, Celery Seed. 5 fl oz
Add to cart

In stock

Sale!
Scorpion Disco Hot Sauce

Karma Sauce Scorpion Disco Hot Sauce

(3 Reviews)

Original price was: $13.99.Current price is: $10.00.

Scorpion Disco Hot Sauce

Karma Sauce Scorpion Disco Hot Sauce joins Extreme Karma and Burn After Eating as Karma Sauce’s third sauce to be featured on the hit YouTube series Hot Ones! A 2021 Fiery Food Challenge 1st Place Golden Chile recipient in the Ghost Pepper Sauce category, Scorpion Disco is an eclectic blend of spices and ultra-hot peppers, making it an indispensable companion in the quest for meals that matter. Heat Level: Extremely Hot Ingredients: peppers (Trinidad Scorpion, Ghost, Chocolate Habanero, 7 Pot Primo), apple cider vinegar, cane sugar, fresh lime juice, salt, garlic, spices.

Scorpion Disco Scoville: 649,000

5oz
Add to cart

In stock

Sale!
Harladay Hots Spicy Meat Sauce

Harladay Hots Meat Sauce

(7 Reviews)

Original price was: $9.99.Current price is: $8.99.
Harladay Hots Spicy Meat Sauce Since 2010, Harladay Hots has been a summertime favorite in Pittsford, NY. Its signature spicy meat sauce has won the hearts (and taste buds) of loyal customers. What started as a cherished family recipe—once reserved for picnics and...
Add to cart

In stock

Karma Sauce Ghost Island Hot Sauce

Karma Sauce Ghost Island Hot Sauce

(1 Review)

$9.99

Ghost Island Hot Sauce

A "Caribbean flavor to die for". Pineapple and mango are mixed with Naga Jolokia aka Ghost peppers for a scary good sauce! Heat Level: Hot Ingredients: peppers (habanero, fatalii, ghost), orange juice, apple cider vinegar, mango, pineapple, organic sugar, mustard seed, lime juice, water, agave nectar, salt, onion, curry spices, garlic. 5oz
Add to cart

In stock

Sale!
Craft Cannery Slow. Steak Sauce

Slow. Steak Sauce

Original price was: $6.99.Current price is: $5.99.
Craft Cannery Slow. Steak Sauce This tangy steak sauce is oh-so-slow-simmered in stainless steel kettles for hours, so it can develop a balanced smoky flavor that pairs perfectly with your most handsome hunk of beef. Our friends swear that this delicious sauce makes...
Add to cart

In stock

Sale!
Suave Sauce Veggie

Suavé Sauce Meat Hot Sauce – Veggie

(4 Reviews)

Original price was: $9.99.Current price is: $8.99.
Flavor: Veggie
Add to cart

In stock

Chef James' Bourbon Meat Sauce

Chef James’ Bourbon Meat Sauce

(1 Review)

$8.99
Chef James’ Bourbon Meat Sauce Take a piece of Lovin’ Cup home with you! Sous Chef James’s signature meat hot sauce recipe takes a unique spin with the addition of Iron Smoke Distillery Bourbon Whiskey! Simmer and serve on Medium Low. Like it...
Add to cart

In stock

Guglielmo's Spicy Chunky Veggie Pasta Sauce

Guglielmo's Pasta Sauce – Spicy Chunky Veggie

$7.99
Flavor: Spicy Chunky Veggie
Add to cart

In stock

Guglielmo's Vodka Pasta Sauce

Guglielmo's Pasta Sauce – Vodka

$7.99
Flavor: Vodka
Add to cart

In stock

Karma Sauce It's Tuesday Somewhere Hot Sauce

Karma Sauce It’s Tuesday Somewhere Hot Sauce

$7.99

It’s Tuesday Somewhere Hot Sauce

Accents of jalapeno, heirloom tomatoes, and fresh lime. Tuesday will never be the same! Awards: 2023 Spicy Flave Awards - 2nd Place - Latin Hot Sauces 2020 Golden Chile Winner for Latin-style Mild Sauce Heat Level: Mild Ingredients: Tomato, Onion, Jalapeno Peppers, Fresh Lime Juice, Agave Nectar, Salt, Garlic, Chipotle Chile, Cumin, Black Pepper, Mexican Oregano 5oz
Add to cart

In stock

Karma Sauce Splash Down Hot Sauce

Karma Sauce Splash Down Hot Sauce

$7.99

Splash Down Hot Sauce

A Thai curry-inspired hot sauce. Coconut, lemongrass, basil, and lime juice splash down to create a wave of flavor that only Karma Sauce can provide! Awards: 2023 Spicy Flave Awards - 1st Place - Asian Hot Sauces Heat Level: Medium Ingredients: Red chiles, vinegar (infused with galangal, lemongrass and kaffir lime leaf), lime juice, coconut water, coconut sugar, garlic, salt, toasted onion, Thai chile flake, Thai basil, culantro, spices Contains: Coconut 5oz
Add to cart

In stock

PepperNutz Salsa Verde Hot Sauce

PepperNutz Salsa Verde Hot Sauce

(1 Review)

$6.99
PepperNutz Salsa Verde Hot Sauce A flavor explosion featuring everything that makes an authentic Mexican salsa verde sauce, including a select 4-pepper blend combined with goodies like agave nectar, lime, scallions, avocados, cilantro and other fresh ingredients. Heat Level: Medium Ingredients: Jalapeno Peppers, Crushed...
Add to cart

In stock

Sale!
Craft Cannery Slow. BBQ Sauce

Slow. BBQ Sauce

Original price was: $7.99.Current price is: $6.99.
Craft Cannery Slow. BBQ Sauce A little sweet. A little smoky. A lot slooow. Craft Cannery uses human hands to painstakingly cook every single batch of their BBQ sauce in stainless steel kettles, to let all those delicious spices rise up and tickle...
Add to cart

In stock

Slow Rochester Meat Sauce

Slow. Rochester Meat Sauce

(2 Reviews)

$9.99
Slow. Rochester Meat Sauce The people of Rochester like things slow, spicy, and above all, MEATY. That’s why the first ingredient in this sauce is real beef from a real mooing cow. This deliciously slow-cooked spicy meat sauce belongs on your burger, on...
Add to cart

In stock

Sale!
Suave Sauce Bomb-Ass Hot Sauce

Suavé Sauce Bomb-Ass Hot Sauce

Original price was: $10.99.Current price is: $9.99.
Bomb-Ass Hot Sauce A little goes a long way! Suavé Sauce’s entry into the “pepper” hot sauce realm is a wickedly hot mashup of Ghost Peppers combined with peaches and pineapples. Contains Soy, Fish 5 fl oz
Add to cart

In stock

Guglielmo's Marinara Pasta Sauce

Guglielmo's Pasta Sauce – Marinara

$7.99
Flavor: Marinara
Add to cart

In stock

Guglielmo's Butternut Squash Pasta Sauce

Guglielmo's Pasta Sauce – Butternut Squash

$7.99
Flavor: Butternut Squash
Add to cart

In stock

Guglielmo's Rosa Pasta Sauce

Guglielmo's Pasta Sauce – Rosa

$7.99
Flavor: Rosa
Add to cart