*All Orders 4/19-4/27 Will Ship 4/28*

Shipping Simplified: $7.95 Flat Rate, Free $69+ or Free Delivery ($39+) in Monroe County, NY

Check Our Freebies List!

All Orders $69+

Cart

No products in the cart.

Return To Shop
Shopping cart (0)
Subtotal: $0.00

View cart

Cart $0.00
2 columns grid
3 columns grid
4 columns grid
List
More
Show

Out of stock

Karma Sauce Curry Karma Hot Sauce

Karma Sauce Curry Karma Hot Sauce

$6.99
Curry Karma Inject some excitement into your usual dinner routine. Curry Karma combines curry and tamarind with mango to take your next meal to another level of flavor. Heat Level: Medium Ingredients: red pepper, butternut squash, apple cider vinegar, onion, sweet potato, honey, mango,...
Read more

Out of stock

Fig Balsamic Vinegar

Fig Balsamic Vinegar

$17.99
Fig Balsamic Vinegar Just one ingredient. That’s all it takes to change the flavor profile of any dish you’re making. If you really want to try something new and put a real flavor punch into your next meal, we have a solution for...
Read more

In stock

Karma Sauce It's Tuesday Somewhere Hot Sauce

Karma Sauce It’s Tuesday Somewhere Hot Sauce

$6.99
It’s Tuesday Somewhere Hot Sauce Accents of jalapeno, heirloom tomatoes, and fresh lime. Tuesday will never be the same! Awards: 2023 Spicy Flave Awards – 2nd Place – Latin Hot Sauces 2020 Golden Chile Winner for Latin-style Mild Sauce Heat Level: Mild Ingredients:...
Add to cart

In stock

BTB Bar & Grill Meat Hot Sauce

BTB Bar & Grill Meat Hot Sauce

$8.99
BTB Meat Hot Sauce You can now have BTB Wood Fired Pizza Bar & Grill’s meat hot sauce at home! Winner of the 2024 Roc City Meat Hot Sauce Fest’s Best Traditional meat hot sauce. 16oz
Add to cart

In stock

Slow Rochester Meat Sauce

Slow. Rochester Meat Sauce

$9.99
Slow. Rochester Meat Sauce The people of Rochester like things slow, spicy, and above all, MEATY. That’s why the first ingredient in this sauce is real beef from a real mooing cow. This deliciously slow-cooked spicy meat sauce belongs on your burger, on...
Add to cart

Out of stock

PepperNutz Pineapple Hot Sauce

PepperNutz Pineapple Hot Sauce

$6.99
PepperNutz Pineapple Hot Sauce An all-natural hot sauce with a flavorful blast of pineapple and oranges with hints of ginger, garlic, onions and honey. 5oz
Read more

In stock

Guglielmo's Vodka Sauce

Guglielmo’s Vodka Sauce

$7.99
Guglielmo’s Vodka Pasta Sauce This Rochester pasta sauce collaboration brings together local favorites—Black Button, Rubino’s, and Pittsford Dairy—for a rich, flavorful sauce crafted with hometown pride. Net. Wt. 23.5oz (665g) Contains: Dairy
Add to cart

In stock

Karma Sauce Huhu Pina Hot Sauce

Karma Sauce Huhu Pina Hot Sauce

$6.99
Huhu Pina This hot sauce will excite your tongue with not just pineapple but Korean Gochugaru and hints of ginger, agave and marjoram. 2020 Fiery Food Challenge Winner – Exotic Hot Sauce & Latin Hot Sauce Heat Level: Mild Ingredients: Pineapple, Smoked Yellow...
Add to cart

Out of stock

Blueberry Balsamic Vinegar

Blueberry Balsamic Vinegar

$17.99
Blueberry Balsamic Vinegar In the simplest terms we can put them in, to make our amazing Blueberry Balsamic Vinegar, we utilize the following process. First, organic grapes are crushed whole. Second, the grapes are boiled down into a syrup. Third, the syrup is...
Read more

Out of stock

Sale!
Karma Sauce Hole Mole Hot Sauce

Karma Sauce Hole Mole Hot Sauce

Original price was: $8.99.Current price is: $6.00.
Hole Mole Hot Sauce Mexican chocolate, dark fruit, and Butternut squash combine with Habaneros for a sweet and spicy experience. Brand: Karma Sauce Heat Level: Medium Ingredients: Blackberry Juice, Habanero Chile, Water, Apple Cider Vinegar, Panela Sugar, Plum Concentrate, Squash Seed Oil, 100% Pure...
Read more

In stock

Blood Orange Olive Oil

Blood Orange Olive Oil

$17.99
Blood Orange Olive Oil To make our Blood Orange Olive Oil, we press olives and blood oranges together, which we’ve found is the best way to impart the flavor of blood oranges to the olive oil. The sweet, tart flavor of blood oranges...
Add to cart

In stock

Guglielmo's Tomato Basil Sauce

Guglielmo’s Tomato Basil Sauce

$7.99
Guglielmo’s Tomato Basil Sauce This pasta sauce is inspired by the tomatoes owner Paul Guglielmo’s grandfather and he canned every September. The simple combo of fresh tomatoes, basil, and parsley makes a great by itself! Net. Wt. 24oz (678g)
Add to cart

In stock

Harladay Hots Spicy Meat Sauce

Harladay Hots Meat Sauce

$9.99
Harladay Hots Spicy Meat Sauce Since 2010, Harladay Hots has been a summertime favorite in Pittsford, NY. Its signature spicy meat sauce has won the hearts (and taste buds) of loyal customers. What started as a cherished family recipe—once reserved for picnics and...
Add to cart

Out of stock

PepperNutz ROC'n Reaper Hot Sauce

PepperNutz ROC’n Reaper Hot Sauce

$7.99
PepperNutz ROC’n Reaper Hot Sauce An all-natural small batch hot sauce with a tomato base and featuring the crazy heat of the Carolina Reaper pepper. 5 fl oz
Read more

Out of stock

PepperNutz Mystic Pizza Hot Sauce

PepperNutz Mystic Pizza Hot Sauce

$6.99
Mystic Pizza Hot Sauce This sauce is all the essence of an Italian kitchen captured in a bottle! Tastes just like a spicy pizza, without the dough or tomatoes! Heat Level: Medium Ingredients: Louisiana Hot Sauce (Aged Red Peppers, Distilled Vinegar, Salt and...
Read more

Out of stock

Bill Gray's Hot Sauce

Bill Gray’s Hot Sauce

$7.99
A Rochester Original Since 1938 More than just a condiment, Bill Gray’s Hot Sauce is an authentic taste of Rochester’s history. Since 1938, Bill Gray’s has been a local institution renowned for serving its legendary “World’s Greatest Cheeseburger” and “Great Plates”, comfort food...
Read more

In stock

Coach Tony's Meat Hot Sauce - Hot

Coach Tony's Gourmet Beef Hot Sauce – Hot

$10.99
Flavor: Hot
Add to cart

Out of stock

Strawberry Balsamic Vinegar

Strawberry Balsamic Vinegar

$17.99
Strawberry Balsamic Vinegar REAL strawberry puree concentrate AND pure essence distilled from real California strawberries. NEVER any artificial or natural flavors. The best strawberry balsamic vinegar you’ll ever have. Ingredients: Organic Balsamic Vinegar (concentrated grape must, white wine vinegar), Strawberry Puree Concentrate, Strawberry...
Read more

Out of stock

PepperNutz Caribbean Rum Hot Sauce

PepperNutz Caribbean Rum Hot Sauce

$6.99
PepperNutz Caribbean Rum Hot Sauce An all-natural small batch hot sauce with a sweet essence and chunkier texture from the light blending of Cayenne and Peri Peri peppers, Caribbean fruits, honey, raisins, and most importantly… DARK RUM! Ingredients: Pineapple, Apple Cider Vinegar, Dark...
Read more

In stock

Karma Sauce Ghost Island Hot Sauce

Karma Sauce Ghost Island Hot Sauce

$9.99
Ghost Island Hot Sauce A “Caribbean flavor to die for”. Pineapple and mango are mixed with Naga Jolokia aka Ghost peppers for a scary good sauce! Heat Level: Hot Ingredients: peppers (habanero, fatalii, ghost), orange juice, apple cider vinegar, mango, pineapple, organic sugar,...
Add to cart

Out of stock

Buddah's Meat Hot Sauce

Buddha’s Meat Hot Sauce

$9.99
Buddha’s Meat Hot Sauce Geno Tavolino, owner of Buddah’s Burgers & Hots, put his heart and soul into his restaurant for all to enjoy. Now, you can enjoy their awesome meat hot sauce at home! Ingredients: Ground Beef, Water, Soybean Oil, Granulated Garlic,...
Read more

Only 1 left in stock

Chef James' Bourbon Meat Sauce

Chef James’ Bourbon Meat Sauce

$8.99
Chef James’ Bourbon Meat Sauce Take a piece of Lovin’ Cup home with you! Sous Chef James’s signature meat hot sauce recipe takes a unique spin with the addition of Iron Smoke Distillery Bourbon Whiskey! 16oz (473.176mL) Simmer and serve on Medium Low....
Add to cart

Out of stock

Death By Chili Sauce - Mild- 5oz

Death By Chili Sauce - Mild – 5oz

$7.99
Size: 5oz
Read more

Out of stock

Red Catastrophe Hot Sauce

Red Catastrophe Hot Sauce

$8.99
Red Catastrophe Hot Sauce Sweet, hot & sassy and this kitty will keep you purring all night. Made with real Red Cat wine from Hazlitt 1852 Vineyards located in the Finger Lakes in beautiful upstate New York. Red Savina Habaneros and garlic duke...
Read more